Evaluation and Comparison of Antioxidant activity of herbomineral Complex
Ms. Shivani Watak*, Dr. Mrs. Swati S. Patil
Prin. K.M. Kundnani
College of Pharmacy, Cuffe Parade, Colaba, Mumbai.
ABSTRACT:
Phenolic compounds
are metal chelator, it is interesting to investigate
Their metal-chelating property, which stimulates our interest to evaluate Zn(II)-chelating ability and the effect of Zn(II) on its
radical-scavenging activity by theoretical calculation. It was revealed that Phenolic compound could efficiently sequester Zn(II) and the Zn(II)-Phenolic
compound complexes were more active than the parent compound in scavenging
radicals by donating proton or electron. Therefore, Phenolic
compounds are a multipotent agent, with the
activities of scavenging ROS, blocking Aβ
aggregation and chelating metal ions
KEYWORDS: metal chelator, antioxidant,
Phenolic compounds
INTRODUCTION:
A large number of herbal drugs possess the wide spectrum of
therapeutic activity. But the potential use of these herbal drugs is limited
due to their poor absorption and poor bioavailability after oral administration.
Phenolic compounds constitute a diversified group of
plant secondary metabolites in terms of structure, molecular weight and
physicochemical and biological properties. They exhibit strong antioxidant
properties. Antioxidant properties can result from their free radical
scavenging activity. But major drawback of phenolic
compound is their poor bioavailability(1) Literature resources
reveled that formation of complex of these phenolic
compound with mineral will increase bioavailability and free radical
scavenging activity Their ability to chelate
transition metal ions, can generate highly reactive oxygen free radicals by
Fenton or Haber-Weiss chemistry. In the Fenton reaction the hydroxyl radical
(HO•) is produced from hydrogen peroxide. In the iron-catalyzed
Haber-Weiss reaction the superoxide radical (O2•−)
reduces ferric to ferrous ions, which then are again involved in generating of
hydroxyl radical. Extremely reactive hydroxyl radicals can interact with many
biological macro- and small molecules and therefore lead to lipid peroxidation, DNA damage and polymerization or denaturation of proteins. The binding of transition metal
ions by phenolic compounds can stabilize prooxidative activity of those ions.(2)
Yet data on complexing of ion metals by tannins
isolated from plant extracts are scarce. Therefore, the aim of this study was
to examine their ability to chelate Zn (II). The
knowledge of those properties can be applied in future studies aimed at
elucidating the mechanisms of antioxidant and anticancer activity.
EXPERIMENTAL:
Comparison of antioxidant activity of Catechin,
Curcumin and Trigonella
foenum graecum extract
and their complexes with zinc by following method
1- diphenyl-2-picryl hydrazyl (DPPH) free radical scavenging activity.
Lipid peroxidation
inhibition method.
1-diphenyl-2-picryl hydrazyl (DPPH) free
radical scavenging activity (3)
Principle
1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl(α,α-diphenyl-β picrylhydrazyl; DPPH
[1] is characterised as a stable free radical by
virtue of the delocalisation of the spare electron
over the molecule as a whole, so that the molecules do not dimerise,
as would be the case with most other free radicals. The delocalisation
also gives rise to the deep violet colour, characterised by an absorption band in ethanol solution at
about 520 nm.
When a solution of DPPH is mixed with a substance that can donate
a hydrogen atom, then this gives rise to the reduced form [2] with the loss of
this violet colour(although there would be expected
to be a residual pale yellow colour from the picryl group still present). Representing the DPPH radical
by Z• and the donor molecule by AH, the primary reaction is
Z• + AH = ZH + A•
Where ZH is the reduced form and A• is free radical produced in
this first step. This latter radical will then undergo further reactions which
control the overall stoichiometry, that is, the
number of molecules of DPPH reduced (decolorised) by
one molecule of the reductant.
The reaction is therefore intended to provide the link with the
reactions taking place in an oxidising system, such
as the autoxidation of a lipid or other unsaturated
substance; the DPPH molecule Z• is thus intended to represent the free radicals
formed in the system whose activity is to be suppressed by the substance AH
[1] [2]
1,1-diphenyl-2-picryl-hydrazyl1,1-diphenyl-2-picryl-hydrazine
1, 1- diphenyl-2-picryl hydrazyl (DPPH)
Preparation of test material
Extraction of Trigonella foenum graecum seeds was
carried in soxhlet extractor using methanol solvent.
The dried seeds were powdered, then extraction
followed with methanol. After completion of extraction the solvent was
evaporated in evaporating dish on the water bath to obtain dry extract. Extract
of Trigonella foenum
graecum were reconstituted in methanol to get
different concentration like 10, 20, 40, 60, 80 and100 μg/ml
and used for assay.
Herbomineral complex of Catechin,
Curcumin and Trigonella
foenum graecum extract
was formed with zinc. Complex was formed
in the form of precipitates, solvent was evaporated in evaporating dish and
dried precipitates were collected and reconstituted in methanol to get
different concentration like 10 ,20 , 40, 60, 80 and100 μg/ml
and used for assay.
Methodology (4)
DPPH, a stable nitrogen centered radical
was used to assess the hydrogen donating ability of Catechin, Curcumin, methanolic extract of Trigonella foenum graecum and their complexes, as it offers a convenient
and accurate method because of the relatively short time required for analysis.
The reaction mixture consisted of 1 ml of
0.1mM DPPH in methanol, 0.95 ml of 0.05 M Tris-HCl
buffer (pH 7.4), 1 ml of methanol and 0.05 ml of methanolic solution of Catechin
complex, Curcumin complex and extract of Trigonella
foenum graecum and its
complex at various concentrations (10,
20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 µg/ml).Catechin, Curcumin being a phenolic
compound was used as positive control, added to a series of other test tubes
instead of the complexes
The absorbance of
the mixture was measured at 517 nm exactly after 30 mins.
The % of scavenging activity was determined
by comparing the result of Catechin complex, Curcumin complex, Trigonella
foenum graecum extract
complex with those of standard antioxidant Catechin, Curcumin and Trigonella
foenum graecum extract.The
radical scavenging activity was expressed as the inhibition percentage and
monitored as per the equation:
Inhibition (%) = [(control
− test) ×100] / control
The result was expressed as IC50 value that is the
concentration of extract required for 50% inhibition of DPPH radicals
The inhibition in free hydroxyl radical scavenging activity of Catechin complex, Curcumin
complex and Trigonella foenum
graecum extract
and its complex were calculated
using following graphs and the results are as shown in the table 1.3
Figure 1.2 Plot of %
Inhibition Vs Concentration Catechin hydrate
Figure 1.3 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Catechin hydrate complex
`Figure 1.4 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Curcumin
Figure 1.5 Plot of %
Inhibition Vs Concentration Curcumin complex
Figure 1.6 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Trigonella foenum graecum seed extract
Figure 1.7 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Trigonella foenum graecum seed extract
complex
Table 1.3Results of free
radical scavenging activity by DPPH
Extract |
Concentration (µg/ml) |
% Inhibition |
IC50 (µg/ml) |
Catechin
hydrate |
10 |
28.56 |
35.71 |
20 |
46.56 |
||
40 |
58.12 |
||
60 |
63.77 |
||
80 |
73.35 |
||
100 |
75.98 |
||
Catechin
hydrate complex |
10 |
30.03 |
26.31 |
20 |
45.20 |
||
30 |
69.85 |
||
40 |
77.09 |
||
60 |
80.51 |
||
100 |
80.94 |
||
Curcumin |
10 |
4.77 |
60.29 |
20 |
23.68 |
||
40 |
32.06 |
||
60 |
45.26 |
||
80 |
70.54 |
||
100 |
77.61 |
||
Curcumin
complex |
10 |
8.54 |
53.53 |
20 |
29.41 |
||
40 |
42.01 |
||
60 |
55.77 |
||
80 |
74.86 |
||
100 |
80.88 |
||
Trigonellafoenumgraecum extract complex |
10 |
22.36 |
62.23 |
20 |
23.69 |
||
40 |
27.30 |
||
60 |
48.84 |
||
80 |
68.70 |
||
100 |
70.19 |
||
|
|
||
Trigonellafoenumgraecum extract complex |
10 |
25.81 |
55.89 |
20 |
29.45 |
||
40 |
30.05 |
||
60 |
53.78 |
||
80 |
70.87 |
||
100 |
74.63 |
METHOD:
Lipid Peroxidation
1 Principle
The inhibition in lipid peroxidation of
liver homogenate of mice is used as method to determine the antioxidant
activity of plant extracts. In this method in vitro free radicals were
generated using ferrous ascorbate system. These free
hydroxyl radicals during aerobic incubation with liver homogenate leads to
formation of malonadialdehye (MDA) which reacts with thiobarbituric acid (TBA). The formation of this thiobarbuturic acid reactive substance (TBARs) was
monitored calorimetrically at 532 nm using UV spectrophotometry.
The reaction between lipid peroxides and TBA is used as sensitive method for
lipid peroxidation in animal tissues (5)
Reagents
Required
0.15 M Potassium chloride solution.
Tris buffer.
100 µM ferrous sulphate
100 µM Ascorbic acid
5 % Thiobarbituric
acid
Ice cold saline (0.95 NaCl)
Preparation of test material
The extract of Trigonella foenum graecum and its
complex, Catechin complex and Curcumin
complex were reconstituted in methanol. Catechin, Curcumin was dissolved in methanol which was used as a
positive standard.
Methodology (6)
Mice liver homogenate (10%) was prepared by
homogenizing the fresh liver in 0.15 M KCl solution.
This fresh liver
homogenate was mixed with 0.15 M KCL and tris
hydrochloride buffer.
The test reagents
then added in various concentrations. Catechin and Curcumin was used as
standard.
In vitro lipid peroxidation
was initiated by addition of 100 µM ferrous sulphate and 100 µM Ascorbic acid.
After incubation
for 1 hour at 370C, the reaction was terminated by addition of thiobarbituric acid and then boiled at 950C for
15 minutes for development of colored complex.
On cooling test
tubes were centrifuged at 4000 RPM for 10 minutes.
Absorbance of supernatant was determined by
colorimetrically at 532 nm and percent inhibition of
TBARs formation was calculated with respect to control in which no test sample
was added.
Evaluation
The inhibition of lipid peroxidation was
determined by calculating percent inhibition in formation of TBARs using the
following formula.
% Inhibition = Acontrol– A test
------------------
Acontrol
The IC50 values were calculated for all test material
by subjecting the results to linear regression.
The inhibition in lipid peroxidation
of Trigonella foenum
graecum extract and its complex as well as Catechin complex and Curcumin
complex were calculated using following
graphs and the results are as shown in the table 1.4
Figure.
1.9 Plot of % Inhibition Vs Concentration Catechin
hydrate
Figure 1.10 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Catechin hydrate complex
Figure1.11 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Curcumin
Figure 1.12 Plot of % Inhibition Vs Concentration Curcumin complex
Figure 1.13 Plot of % Inhibition Vs
Concentration Trigonella foenum graecum seed extract
Figure.
1.14 Plot of % Inhibition Vs Concentration Trigonella
foenum graecum seed
extract complex
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
The evaluation and comparison of
antioxidant activity of Catechin, Curcumin
and Trigonella foenum
graecum extract and their herbomineral
complex by DPPH and by lipidperoxidation method
showed increase in free radical scavenging activity by forming complex with
zinc.
Catechins are widely known to be very potent
antioxidants. They are able to scavenge reactive oxygen species (ROS) before
ROS can cause damage to the cell. Catechin is able to
scavenge free radicals directly by hydrogen atom donation,
antioxidant activity depends on the arrangement of functional groups on its
core structure. Both the configuration and total number of hydroxyl groups
substantially influence the mechanism of antioxidant activity The B ring
hydroxyl configuration is the most significant determinant of ROS scavenging. Catechins are excellent in vitro antioxidants due to the
high number of hydroxyl groups in their molecules. Catechins
were effective in scavenging peroxyl radicals in the
liposomal system. criteria for effective
radical scavenging are (a) the o-dihydroxyl
structure in the B ring, which confers higher stability to the radical form and
participate in electron delocalization, (b) the 2,3-double
bond in conjugation with a 4-oxo function in the C ring, which is responsible
for electron delocalization from the B ring, and (c) the 3- and 5-OH groups
with 4-oxo function in the A and C rings for maximum radical scavenging
potential. (7)
Table 1.4 Results of free
radical scavenging activity by Lipid Peroxidation
method
Extracts |
Concentration (µg/ml) |
% inhibition in
TBARS Formation |
IC50 (µg/ml) |
Catechin
hydrate. |
10 |
32.06 |
43.19 |
20 |
35.34 |
||
40 |
48.76 |
||
60 |
59.43 |
||
80 |
71.60 |
||
100 |
75.14 |
||
Catechinhyrate complex |
10 |
34.09 |
37.00 |
20 |
41.98 |
||
40 |
51.95 |
||
60 |
63.47 |
||
80 |
73.74 |
||
100 |
76.19 |
||
Curcumin |
10 |
13.5 |
70.98 |
20 |
28.65 |
||
40 |
34.84 |
||
60 |
44.76 |
||
80 |
52.08 |
||
100 |
66.16 |
||
Curcumin
complex |
10 |
23.95 |
55.69 |
20 |
31.43 |
||
40 |
42.53 |
||
60 |
53.72 |
||
80 |
63.82 |
||
100 |
71.82 |
||
Trigonellafoenumgraecumextract |
10 |
26.12 |
42.90 |
20 |
38.31 |
||
40 |
52.39 |
||
60 |
65.39 |
||
80 |
68.43 |
||
100 |
78.84 |
||
Trigonellafoenumgraecumextract
complex |
10 |
39.14 |
22.63 |
20 |
50.68 |
||
40 |
61.79 |
||
60 |
68.32 |
||
80 |
74.33 |
||
100 |
80.52 |
The antioxidant mechanism of Curcumin
was a H-atom abstraction from the phenolic
group. The antioxidant activity of Curcumin (1,7-bis(4-hydroxy-3-methoxyphenyl)-1,6-heptadiene-3,5-dione)
was determined by inhibition of controlled initiation of styrene oxidation.
Synthetic Curcumin is a classical phenolic
chain-breaking antioxidant, donating H atoms from the phenolic
groups not the CH2 group as has been suggested (8)
Flavonoids belong to a large family of compound with
a common diphenylpropane structure (C6C3C6) with
different degree of hydroxylation, oxidation and substitution. Flavonoids have been reported to be able to interfere with
the activities of enzyme involved in the reactive oxygen species generation,
quenching free radicals, chelating transition metals and rendering them redox inactive. Thus the flavonoids
present in Trigonella foenum graecum extract
may be responsible for its antioxidant activity. (9)
These are the possible different mechanism
by which Catechin, Curcumin
and Trigonella foenum
graecum extract gives free radical scavenging
activity.
Hrebomineral complex of Catechin,
Curcumin and Trigonella
foenum graecum extract
was prepared by the process of chelation. Chelation form a special kind of bond, called a coordinate
covalent bond, with the ions of certain metals. If all the requirements are
met, then bingo—the metal ion is grabbed and “locked up” in the chelator’s clawlike embrace. The
resulting molecular entity, called a coordination complex, is typically
very stable and will not easily yield back the metal ion. Thus, if this complex
is excreted, metal ions go with drug.
The protonated phenolic
group is not a particularly good ligand for metal cations, but once deprotonated,
an oxygen center is generated that possesses a high charge density, a so-called
"Hard" ligand. Although the pKa value of most phenols is in the region of 9.0-10.0, in
the presence of suitable cations for instance iron(III) or copper(H), the proton is displaced at much
lower pH values, e.g., 5.0-8.0. Thus metal chelation
by phenols can occur at physiological pH values
For good scavenging activity,
a catechol moiety on ring B is required. The 3-OH
moiety can function as a chelation site and can also
be oxidized. The 3-OH group in combination with a C2 C3 double bond increases
the scavenging activity. Chelation can then raise the
activity to the level of the most active scavengers; possibly by site-specific
scavenging .Thus chelation will increase antioxidant
activity by site- specific scavenging (10)
From the literature search it
was revealed that excess Zn will suppress absorption of iron and copper, which
are the trace metals responsible for producing oxidative stress. Hence
oxidative stress produced by these trace metals is suppressed. Thus increase
antioxidant activity.
Zinc itself is a good
antioxidant. Mechanism of antioxidation for zinc can
be divided into acute and chronic effects. Chronic effects involve exposure of
an organism to zinc on a long-term basis, resulting in induction of some other
substance that is the ultimate antioxidant, such as the metallothioneins.
Chronic zinc deprivation generally results in increased sensitivity to some
oxidative stress. The acute effects involve two mechanisms: protection of
protein sulfhydryls or reduction of ·OH
formation from H2O2 through the antagonism of redox-active transition metals, such as iron and copper.
Protection of protein sulfhydryl groups is thought to
involve reduction of sulfhydryl reactivity through
one of three mechanisms: (1) direct binding of zinc to the sulfhydryl, (2) steric
hindrance as a result of binding to some other protein site in close proximity
to the sulfhydryl group or (3) a
conformational change from binding to some other site on the protein.
Antagonism of redox-active, transition
metal-catalyzed, site-specific reactions has led to the theory that zinc may be
capable of reducing cellular injury that might have a component of
site-specific oxidative damage, such as postischemic
tissue damage (11)
Catechin ,Curcumin and flavonoids
present in Trigonella foenum
graecum extract showed potent antioxidant
activity invitro, but due to their poor
bioavailability these are not that much effective in vivo. From the literature
search if the pharmacokinetic of Zn and these compounds were compared, chelation with Zn will increase the bioavailability of poorly bioavailable drug. Catechin and flavonoids are excreted through urine, where as90% zinc is
excreted in feaces, and small traces in urine due to reabsorption of zinc occurs in kidney. Thus the complex
will reabsorb and gives free radical scavenging activity for longer period of
time. But in case of Curcumin, both Curcumin and zinc are excreted through feaces.
Hence bioavailability of Curcumin is not increased.
Catechin, curcumin and Trigonella foenum graecum extract showed good antioxidant activity by
their own mechanism. Formation of complex, will
increase activity in vitro due to site specific
scavenging, suppression of absorption of trace metals responsible for producing
oxidative stress and antioxidant activity of Zinc. Also, invivo by increasing bioavailability. Thus hrebomineral complex will added more way and gives
synergistic and multifunctional activity.
REFERENCES
1. Min Zhu, Yu Chen,
Ronald C. Li, Oral
Absorption and Bioavailability of Tea Catechins Department of Pharmacy, The Chinese University
of Hong Kong, Thieme
eJournals Planta Med
2000; 66(5): 444-447
2. Magdalena Karamac,
Division of food science, Institute of Animal Reproduction and Food Research,
Polish Academy of Sciences, Pol. J. Food Nutr. Olsztyn,Poland December
2009.Tuwima (10), 10-747
3. Kai Marxen , Klaus Heinrich Vanselow , Sebastian Lippemeier ,
Ralf Hintze , Andreas Ruser and Ulf-Peter Hansen Determination of DPPH Radical Oxidation Caused by Methanolic
Extracts of Some Microalgal Species by Linear
Regression Analysis of Spectrophotometric Measurements Sensors 2007,(7)2080-2095
4. Rajbir Singh,
Bikram Singh, Sukhpreet Singh
Neeraj Kumar, Subodh Kumar,
Saroj Arora, Anti-free
radical activities of kaempferol isolated from Acacia
nilotica (L.) Willd. Ex. Del.
Department of Botanical and Environmental Sciences, Guru Nanak Dev University,
Amritsar-143 005, Punjab, India Toxicol In Vitro. 2008 Dec; 22(8):1965-70.
5. D’Mello P. M., Jadhav M. A., Jolly C. I., “ Free radical scavenging activity of Syzygium
cumin iand Ficus bengalensis- Plants used in the Ayurveda
for diabetes mellitus”, Indian Drugs,
2000;( 37) pp. 518-520.
6. Okhawa, H., Oshishi,N., Yagi,K., Assay for Lipid Peroxidation
in Animal Tissues by Thiobarbituric Acid Reaction,
Anal. Biochem,
1979, (95 )
pp.351-358.
7. D.Prochazkova, I. Bousova,
M.wilhelmova,. Department of Biochemical science, Charles University in Prague,
faculty of pharmacy in Hardee Karlove. Fitoterapia . June 2011,(vol.82), issue 4.
Page no. 516
8. Barclay LR, Vinqvist MR, Mukai K, Goto H, Hashimoto Y, Tokunaga A, Uno H On
the antioxidant mechanism of curcumin:
classical methods are needed to determine antioxidant mechanism and activity. Org Lett.
2000 Sep7, 2(18) :2841-3
9. Saskia
A. B. E. Van Acker, Dirk-jan Van Den Berg, Mich Čl N. J. L. Tromp Désirée H. Griffioen, Wout P. Van Bennekom, Wim J. F. Van Der Vijgh and Aalt Bast Structural aspects of antioxidant activity
of flavonoids LACDR, Division of Molecular
Pharmacology, Department of Pharmacochemistry,
Faculty of Chemistry, Vrije Universiteit,
De Boelelaan, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Free Radical Biology and Medicine ,
1996, (Volume 20) Issue 3, Pages 331-342
10. Tammy M. Bray and William J. Bettger The
physiological role of zinc as an
antioxidant department of Nutritional Sciences, College of Biological
Science University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario, Canada Free Radical Biology and Medicine 1990,
(Volume 8), Issue 3, Pages
281-291
11. Saul R. Powell The Antioxidant Properties of Zinc,
The American Society for Nutritional Sciences Journal of Nutrition.
2000, (130) 1447S-1454S
Received on 12.03.2012
Modified on 15.03.2012
Accepted on 18.03.2012
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry.
4(3): May-June 2012,
171-177